19 Nov 2026 CSA 2 – Maintaining Cybersecurity is not Standardisation
ISACs as Trusted Communities for Cybersecurity Certification Maintenance
Executive summary
Cybersecurity certification requires expertise beyond the ESO remit
Eurosmart calls for the removal of the “ESO-first” approach in the draft ITRE report on the Cybersecurity Act revision. European standardisation organisations (ESOs) develop common requirements for security, functionality and interoperability. Harmonised standards help manufacturers demonstrate conformity with the legal requirements they cover. The ongoing maintenance of a cybersecurity certification scheme falls outside that standardisation remit. Making ENISA’s ability to issue a technical specification conditional on the availability of a suitable European standard would put the maintenance of certification schemes on the wrong footing.
Security assurance is the purpose of certification
A cybersecurity certification scheme exists to provide assurance about the security properties of a product, component or service within a defined scope and at a stated assurance level. Certification evidence can support a demonstration of regulatory conformity where the scope of the evaluation covers the relevant legal requirement. Maintaining that assurance requires specialists who can assess whether evaluation methods still reflect current threats and whether laboratories apply them consistently. A standard can remain valid while the methods used to evaluate its requirements need to change.
ISACs already provide specialist expertise for scheme maintenance
That expertise already exists. The EUCC ISAC shows how technical groups can bring together evaluation laboratories, certification bodies, manufacturers and public authorities to compare findings from actual evaluations and develop proposals for scheme maintenance. When laboratories interpret the same requirement differently, the relevant group can examine the cases and propose a common interpretation. It can also review sensitive findings in confidence and advise ENISA when an evaluation method needs to change. Other schemes should be able to draw on existing specialist communities or develop their own as the need arises.
NCCAs are best placed to support consistent application across Member States
Member State expertise is essential to consistent application across the Union. National cybersecurity certification authorities (NCCAs) are best placed to identify differences in how schemes are applied because they oversee certification practice in their Member States. They should have a formal role in bringing those differences to the attention of ENISA and the European Cybersecurity Certification Group (ECCG) and reviewing whether proposed changes can be applied consistently. The technical groups can help establish what needs to change. The NCCAs can assess how that change will work in practice across Member States.
ENISA should retain responsibility for technical specifications
ENISA, supported by the ECCG, should decide through the scheme’s maintenance process when to issue, revise or withdraw a technical specification. The citation of a European standard should trigger a review where relevant, with ENISA determining whether laboratories still need the specification to apply the scheme consistently. Under Article 75, each maintenance strategy should define how NCCAs contribute and identify the ISAC or equivalent trusted technical community that will support the scheme. This would give practical effect to the role for ISACs recognised in Recital 88 of the Commission proposal.
2026_10_27_CSA2-Certification-Standardisation

